Ethereum, the second-largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization, has long been viewed as a cornerstone of the decentralized finance (DeFi) and smart contract ecosystem. However, recent analysis suggests that its momentum may be lagging—especially when compared to Bitcoin. As investors look ahead to 2025, questions are mounting: Will Ethereum finally break out in a long-awaited "catch-up rally"? Or is it poised to underperform once again?
According to Markus Thielen, Head of Research at 10x Research, Ethereum might not be the smartest bet for those seeking strong bullish momentum in 2025.
"While we can't rule out new catalysts, we wouldn't be surprised if Ethereum fails to deliver significant gains over the next year."
Thielen’s stance is clear and firm: Ethereum is not an attractive mid-term investment, and its performance in 2025 is likely to trail behind Bitcoin’s.
Why Ethereum Could Underperform in 2025
One of the core arguments against Ethereum’s near-term upside potential lies in its lack of compelling fundamental demand beyond staking. While the network remains technically robust, critics argue that real-world utility and investor sentiment have plateaued.
Thielen highlights a concerning trend: the number of active Ethereum validators has turned negative, declining by approximately 1% over the past 30 days. This outflow suggests growing uncertainty among stakers, who may be withdrawing their ETH due to diminishing returns or shifting interest toward more efficient alternatives.
👉 Discover how market sentiment shapes crypto trends and what it means for your next move.
The lack of "real demand" outside staking undermines Ethereum’s value proposition. Unlike Bitcoin, which benefits from its narrative as digital gold and a macro hedge, Ethereum struggles to communicate a unified investment thesis. Its use cases—ranging from DeFi to NFTs to Layer-2 scaling—are diverse but fragmented.
Tim Lowe, Chief Commercial Officer at Attestant, offers a counterpoint. He believes Ethereum’s demand can be revitalized through better marketing and a clearer value narrative. For instance, positioning ETH as a diversification tool beyond Bitcoin could attract new institutional and retail interest.
Yet so far, market data tells a different story.
Bitcoin vs. Ethereum: A Growing Performance Gap
Since January 1, 2024, Bitcoin has surged by 121.4%, while Ethereum has returned just 46.3%—less than half the growth. This widening gap reflects deeper structural shifts in investor behavior.
The launch of spot Bitcoin ETFs in January 2024 was a game-changer. Within two months, these products drove massive inflows—$35.3 billion** in total—fueling Bitcoin’s rally to new all-time highs. In contrast, spot Ethereum ETFs launched in July 2024 saw only **$2.66 billion in inflows, indicating significantly weaker institutional appetite.
This disparity raises a critical question: Is the market treating Ethereum as a secondary asset in the crypto hierarchy?
Missed Opportunities and Delayed Upgrades
Another factor weighing on Ethereum’s outlook is timing. The network’s Dencun upgrade, rolled out in March 2024, aimed to reduce transaction fees and improve scalability via proto-danksharding. While technically successful, Thielen argues it came six months too late.
By the time Dencun launched, the meme coin boom had already shifted toward cheaper, faster chains like Solana. As a result, much of the speculative energy bypassed Ethereum entirely.
Looking ahead, the planned Pectra upgrade in early 2025 promises further improvements, including larger validator withdrawal limits and enhanced wallet functionality. But Thielen remains skeptical:
"Of Ethereum’s 19 previous upgrades, only two had a noticeable positive impact on price—and both occurred during broader crypto bull markets."
He adds that the three major catalysts expected for Ethereum in 2024—ETF approvals, Dencun, and rising DeFi activity—have largely failed to generate sustained momentum.
👉 Explore how network upgrades influence long-term crypto value and what to watch next.
Bullish Voices: Is There Still Hope?
Not all analysts share Thielen’s bearish view. Some believe Ethereum is consolidating and could be on the verge of a breakout.
Crypto trader Cold Blooded Schiller notes that since December 25, Ethereum has traded in a tight range. He sees two possible outcomes: either an optimistic breakout above resistance levels or a retest of the $3,000 support zone seen on December 20.
Meanwhile, Michael van de Poppe, founder of MN Capital, is more optimistic. He predicts Ethereum could show signs of strength in January 2025:
"If the ETH/BTC exchange rate breaks above 0.04—which it currently sits at 0.03572—I wouldn’t be surprised."
Such a move would signal renewed confidence in Ethereum relative to Bitcoin and could trigger a broader catch-up rally.
Core Keywords Driving Market Sentiment
To align with search intent and enhance SEO visibility, key phrases naturally integrated throughout this analysis include:
- Ethereum 2025 price prediction
- ETH vs BTC performance
- Ethereum staking trends
- Crypto bull market outlook
- Ethereum ETF impact
- Blockchain network upgrades
- Validator outflow concerns
- Catch-up rally potential
These terms reflect what investors are actively searching for—combining technical insights with market psychology and forward-looking speculation.
👉 Stay ahead of the curve with real-time insights into Ethereum's price action and network health.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Why is Ethereum underperforming Bitcoin in 2024–2025?
Ethereum’s underperformance stems from weaker ETF demand, delayed upgrades, and reduced validator activity. While Bitcoin benefits from strong institutional adoption and macro narratives, Ethereum lacks a unified value proposition beyond staking and fragmented dApp usage.
Could Ethereum still experience a catch-up rally?
Yes—it’s possible. If macro conditions improve, institutional interest rebounds, or the Pectra upgrade delivers tangible benefits, Ethereum could see a delayed surge. However, current trends suggest this would require new catalysts not yet priced in.
What does declining validator count mean for Ethereum?
A drop in active validators signals reduced confidence in staking returns or network competitiveness. If this trend continues, it could impact network security and investor perception, especially ahead of major upgrades.
How important is the ETH/BTC ratio?
The ETH/BTC exchange rate is a key gauge of relative strength. A breakout above 0.04 could indicate growing preference for Ethereum, while prolonged weakness below 0.035 may reinforce its status as a secondary asset.
Are Ethereum upgrades still driving price gains?
Historically, most Ethereum upgrades have had little immediate impact on price. Only those launched during strong bull markets—like London or Byzantium—spurred notable rallies. With no clear bull momentum in early 2025, Pectra may follow the same pattern.
Should I invest in Ethereum now?
Investment decisions should align with risk tolerance and time horizon. Given current headwinds—modest ETF inflows, weak validator growth, and technical delays—Ethereum appears less compelling than Bitcoin for conservative investors. However, traders may find opportunities in volatility around upgrade cycles.
While debate continues over Ethereum’s trajectory in 2025, one thing is certain: expectations are low, and sentiment is cautious. Whether this sets the stage for a surprise rebound—or confirms a prolonged period of underperformance—will depend on macro trends, network adoption, and the success of upcoming upgrades. For now, many analysts suggest watching closely… but acting with caution.